What We Do Next

Councilwoman Sandy James (Karen Pittman) aspires to a more compassionate New York. But when a woman from her past, Elsa (Michelle Veintimilla), is released from prison, Sandy worries her detractors will uncover her involvement in Elsa's crime. Sixteen years ago, Sandy and her then-fling, corporate lawyer Paul (Corey Stoll), loaned $500 to a teenage Elsa who sought protection from her abusive father -- not realizing they were buying her a gun with which to kill him.

To protect Sandy's career, she and Paul ask Elsa to lie to a journalist about the source of the funds. But one lie opens the door to blackmail, and when Elsa's parole is violated, she asks Sandy and Paul to corroborate another lie -- forcing them to walk the razor's edge between their morals and the standard judicial process.