Total score 7.0
Rated by 8 users. Scroll down to read reviews.
Average ratings
Age
1-12
13-17
18-25
26-35
36-49
50+
Total
Men votes
- 0
- 0
- 0
- 0
- 0
7.5 2
7.5 2
Women votes
- 0
- 0
- 0
- 0
10 1
6.2 4
7 5
Total votes
- 0
- 0
- 0
- 0
10 1
6.6 7
7.0 8
Distribution of reviews
User reviews
sort by date
by value
helpful
As the baby boomer generation ages, many people are thinking about death, especially those dealing with incurable illnesses. The film features characters who are all quite elderly. It taps into our humanity, though the beginning is rather mediocre. The old mother's habit of living alone is disrupted by her son's arrival, a "Tanguy" phenomenon where an adult son clings to the family home due to economic troubles. The film seems to promote assisted suicide, which is an irritating theme. The dramatic progression is also quite slow.
h2o_@ 12.11.2016 age: 50+ 2,458 reviews High Reviews The Marching Band [2024] 8 Harmonium Symphonique: Histoires sans paroles – Le film [2023] 8 Perdre Mario [2021] 8 Emilia Pérez [2024] 8 Ocean Seen from the Heart [2023] 8 Everything Everywhere All at Once [2022] 8 Divertimento [2022] 8 Ennio [2021] 8 Antigone [2019] 8 The Favourite [2018] 8
Low Reviews Nobody [2021] 4 That Kind of Summer [2022] 4 Deadly Secrets [2022] 4 He's Not Worth Dying For [2022] 4 Out of Season [2023] 4 Le Banquet [2008] 3 The American Trap [2008] 3 The Resident [2011] 3 Sharknado [2013] 3 A Woman's Life [2016] 3 See All 2,458 Reviews
WARNING: This review is hidden because it reveals the content of the film.Click here to show this review.
I went to see this film with some hesitation, as I'm not a big fan of Vincent Lindon because I often have trouble understanding what he's saying. But I'm glad I went, primarily because the acting is superb, particularly by Hélène Vincent. The subject matter also really resonated with me. Putting aside the mother's illness, how can someone cope with the return of a son who acts just like his father, whose passing years earlier brought her a huge sense of relief and freedom? And for the son, how can he avoid constantly feeling like a failure in the eyes of his mother, who sees any disruption as a threat to her stability?
nicoloie@ 12.3.2014 age: 50+ 89 reviews High Reviews Across the Universe [2007] 10 Conclave [2024] 9 Monsieur Aznavour [2024] 9 1995 [2024] 9 Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny [2023] 9 My Mother's Men [2023] 9 The Three Musketeers: D'Artagnan [2023] 9 Green Book [2018] 9 C'est la vie! [2017] 9 Une part d'ombre [2017] 9
Low Reviews Micmacs [2009] 5 The Good Shepherd [2006] 4 The Wolberg Family [2009] 4 Second Round [2023] 4 Wild Grass [2009] 3 Je me souviens [2009] 3 Failure to Launch [2006] 2 Manglehorn [2014] 2 Broken Flowers [2005] 1 Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Lives [2010] 1 See All 89 Reviews
This movie celebrates freedom of choice and encourages respect. Lindon and Vincent portray intricate characters with such raw, powerful performances that it's almost too much to bear because they nail it so perfectly! I absolutely loved this film.
valerie.lalbin@ 19.1.2014 age: 36-49 2 reviews A Few Hours of Spring [2012] 10 Looking for Hortense [2012] 9 See All 2 Reviews
This movie tackles very topical issues that hit us hard, such as the immense difficulty some people have in communicating without painful confrontations. The second issue is planned end-of-life. It's a grim piece, where any attempt by outsiders to break through the loneliness and near-total isolation of a woman and her son is bound to fail. Although the film leaves a bitter taste, it does prompt reflection on respecting the choices made by people facing a complete loss of control over their lives and physical and/or mental suffering they find unacceptable. Hélène Vincent delivers an admirable performance as an actress.
lemlou48@ 19.1.2014 age: 50+ 5 reviews Arwad [2013] 10 Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom [2013] 8 A Few Hours of Spring [2012] 7 Tenderness [2013] 7 Miss and the Doctors [2013] 6 See All 5 Reviews
WARNING: This review is hidden because it reveals the content of the film.Click here to show this review.
This is a tough, emotionally devastating, and weighty film. The characters show a great deal of restraint, with their emotions seldom expressed except through Alain's anger (portrayed excellently by Vincent Lindon). The film drags in parts. The topic of assisted suicide is handled with care and sensitivity. In the end, it seems that the mother and son were unable to reestablish a truly meaningful and healing dialogue.
louise.c@ 16.1.2014 age: 50+ 26 reviews High Reviews Infiltration [2017] 9 Maria by Callas [2017] 9 It's the Heart That Dies Last [2017] 9 Manchester by the Sea [2016] 9 A Kid [2016] 9 Brooklyn [2015] 9 Dheepan [2015] 9 Fatima [2015] 9 Un + une [2015] 9 Mommy [2014] 9
Low Reviews The Patience Stone [2012] 7 Gravity [2013] 7 Domestic Life [2014] 7 Paris Follies [2014] 7 A Few Hours of Spring [2012] 6 See All 26 Reviews
Many scenes in this film feel like filler, such as the interactions between the mother and son, or the son's encounter with a girl where they barely talk. The movie drags on for a long time...
doiron_doiron@ 13.1.2014 age: 50+ 2 reviews The White Ribbon [2009] 5 A Few Hours of Spring [2012] 2 See All 2 Reviews
The film reaches its peak with the "Pieta" scene at the very end. Such determination. Such anguish. Such surrender. A deeply moving film in its harshness, violence, and intensity. A must-see. Mb.
mbernier.psy@ 11.1.2014 age: 50+ 13 reviews Tom at the farm [2013] 10 Hannah Arendt [2012] 10 Winter Sleep [2014] 9 Aurore [2005] 9 The Great Beauty [2013] 8 Adore [2013] 8 Prisoners [2013] 8 Me, Myself and Mum [2013] 8 A Few Hours of Spring [2012] 8 Jappeloup: L'étoffe d'un champion [2013] 7 A Respectable Family [2012] 7 Miraculum [2013] 6 Camille Claudel, 1915 [2013] 4 See All 13 Reviews
This movie puts us through a whole spectrum of emotions. There were times when I literally jumped in my seat due to the raw intensity of the dialogue and actions, and other moments that moved me to tears with their sheer beauty. The two main characters' stoic demeanor is truly powerful, as is the rather unexpected conclusion. Vincent Lindon delivers an outstanding performance, despite his character's late-developing sensitivity. Hélène Vincent shines in her role as a woman burdened by life and fate. It seems that 2012, with films like "Amour" and "A Few Hours of Spring", was a year focused on exploring the end of life....
jpflip@ 2.3.2013 age: 50+ 2,122 reviews High Reviews Blade Runner 2049 [2017] 10 A Royal Affair [2012] 10 The Intouchables [2011] 10 Café de flore [2011] 10 In a Better World [2010] 10 Senna [2010] 10 Biutiful [2010] 10 The Secret in Their Eyes [2009] 10 Okuribito [2008] 10 After The Wedding [2007] 10
Low Reviews Wild Grass [2009] 3 Duplicity [2009] 3 Legion [2010] 3 Longlegs [2024] 3 Gladiator II [2024] 3 National Security [2003] 2 Happy Camper [2004] 2 Miami Vice [2006] 2 3:10 to Yuma [2007] 2 Les Dangereux [2002] 1 See All 2,122 Reviews
~ The End ~
Add Your Review
Please note: Movie reviews on CinemaClock reflect the personal opinions of our users and not necessarily those of CinemaClock. CinemaClock is not responsible for their content.